TL;DR
Get cleaning gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Matter Alpha’s first-month account describes replacing most Zigbee devices in a new apartment with Matter-compatible gear for lighting, controls, climate, sensors and power monitoring. The writer says the setup is usable but still lacks features found in some older devices, and the report does not establish that every device or function works reliably across platforms.
The writer says they began with existing controllers and cleared out many old device entries, keeping network credentials largely the same. Home Assistant became the primary controller for new Matter devices; selected devices were then shared with Apple Home, while Home Assistant’s cloud service connected the system to Google Home and Amazon Alexa. The report says software options such as eWeLink Cube and Homey Self-Hosted Server were used to bring some proprietary local-network devices into the setup.
Lighting and wall controls came first. The report describes installing about 10 Aqara H2 switches and dimmers using Thread, alongside smart ceiling fixtures, IKEA pendant lights and bulbs from several manufacturers. The writer says the switches can work with neutral-free wiring, which helped with retrofitting the apartment’s existing wall boxes. The account also includes ambient lighting and other devices, but the supplied report excerpt does not provide complete results for every category named in its introduction, including climate, sensors and power monitoring.
The writer’s main criticism is that the Thread-based switches currently offer fewer useful controls than their Zigbee counterparts. They cite missing decoupled relay mode for smart-bulb automations and limited dimmer settings when the devices are exposed through Matter. The report says these shortcomings have led the writer to keep using the switches for now while considering other options for neutral-free installations.
Matter’s Switch Feature Gap
The account illustrates a practical distinction between device compatibility and feature parity. Matter can make it easier to connect products across different smart-home platforms, but a device may not expose every manufacturer-specific control through the standard. For households replacing established Zigbee or proprietary systems, that can affect daily automations as much as whether a device appears in an app.
The report is one person’s experience in one apartment, not a controlled test or broad measure of Matter reliability. Still, it offers a useful real-world check for buyers: confirm that the specific functions they depend on are supported in their chosen controller, rather than relying only on a Matter label or basic compatibility listing.
Products Worth Considering
LG C2 Series 65-Inch OLED evo 4K Smart TV (OLED65C2PUA, 2022)
Levoit Vital 200S-P Smart Air Purifier for Large Rooms
Sonos Era 100 Wireless Smart Speaker, Black
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
From Zigbee to Matter
The writer moved into a larger apartment and used the change as an opportunity to rethink an existing smart-home setup. The previous system combined Zigbee switches, HomeKit fixtures and some Matter lamps. During the first month in the new space, the writer replaced most older Zigbee devices with Matter-capable products across several categories.
The account does not describe a complete removal of every bridge or legacy product. It says some standalone hubs became unnecessary as the writer used Zigbee less, while software-based controllers were adopted for certain integrations. The report also notes that some products can support more than one protocol, so “all-Matter” describes the project’s direction rather than proving that every component operates exclusively on Matter.
““They are no better than their Zigbee counterparts over Matter right now.””
— Matter Alpha report author
Reliability and Feature Coverage
The supplied account does not give a quantified reliability result, such as connection failures, response times or outages over the month. It also does not establish whether the reported switch limitations apply across every Matter controller, firmware version or device configuration. The writer’s experience is specific to their products and setup.
Although the report says the project spans climate, sensors and power monitoring, the available source material does not detail which products were installed in those categories or how they performed. It is also unclear whether the writer will keep the current switches, replace them or change how devices are shared between platforms.
Testing the Setup Further
The writer says they are looking into alternatives for neutral-free wall switches, but gives no purchase or replacement date. Further use of the setup may show whether the missing controls can be addressed through firmware updates, controller changes or different products; the report does not confirm that any such fix is planned.
For readers evaluating a similar move, the immediate next step is to check the exact Matter features supported by each product and platform, especially for automations and dimming. The account’s longer-term verdict remains open: it records the first month of setup, not a final assessment of the system’s durability or performance over time.
Key Questions
What did the Matter Alpha report cover?
It describes the author’s first month setting up a mostly Matter-based smart home in a new apartment, with lighting, wall controls and other device categories. The supplied material gives the most detail about switches and lighting.
Which controller did the author use for new Matter devices?
The author says Home Assistant was the primary controller. Selected devices were shared with Apple Home, and Home Assistant’s cloud service was used to connect with Google Home and Amazon Alexa.
What did the author say was missing from the switches?
The report cites a lack of decoupled relay mode for smart-bulb automations and limited dimmer configuration when the switches are exposed through Matter. Those observations reflect the author’s setup, not necessarily every device or platform combination.
Does the report prove an all-Matter home is reliable?
No. It is an individual first-month account and provides no quantified failure rate or controlled comparison. The author describes the setup and some feature gaps, but broader reliability remains unestablished.
Is the author replacing the wall switches?
The author says they are looking into alternatives for neutral-free switches but does not name a replacement or say when a change will happen. They report continuing to use the current switches for now.
Source: matteralpha.com
